It Had to be You

It Had to be YouBy: Joseph Bologna & Renee Taylor

September 20 – November 9

All Sundays are matinees:
12:00 pm arrival
show 2:00 pm



A romantic story of great dexterity and loving warmth. This fast paced comic miracle tells the story of Theda Blau who wants to find love and success in New York. A funny, funny, and finally touching play.

“This laugh out loud madcap comedy has delightful and spirited dialogue and is a real crowd pleaser.”


  1. Jerry

    How can I find out more about “It had to be you” show? Is it a comedy or romantic drama?

    • Steve Graham

      Yes Jerry,
      This is a great show and is a romantc comedy playing up to November 9th

  2. Sean Cassidy

    What time is the show on Saturday night?

    • Steve Graham

      Thursday, Friday & Saturday.
      Arrival time 6.00 – 6.30 pm, Soup and salad is available at that time…
      Dinner service starts at 6.15 – 6.30 pm followed by an M/C to welcome guests, birthdays, anniversaries, visitors etc…
      show starts 8.00 pm and gets out 10.00 – 10.30 pm
      Sundays – noon arrival with 2 pm show, out around 4.30
      Reservations are required

  3. Stephen

    Is show available without dinner
    What time
    $ /person
    Any discounts available
    senior etc

    • Steve Graham

      Hi Stephen ,
      Yes, you can attend a show without the meal.
      Tickets cost $35.00 each including all tax. Thursday, Friday & Saturday are evening performances and arrival time is 7.45 for our 8.00 pm curtain and Sunday’s are all matinees with 1.45 pm arrival and a 2.00 pm curtain.Reservations are required and we seat ‘show only’ attendees with best available seating at show time & there are no discounts for show only.
      Reservations are required Toll Free 1-866-902-9884 or (905) 472-3085 or
      Great Food ! Great Shows ! Great Price !

  4. Melissa

    Just wondering when your murder mystery dinners are, and the cost for the tickets? We would have around 17 people attending and possibly dinner reservations as well.


    • Steve Graham

      Herongate no longer presents Murder Mystery dinners.. We do however have Dinner Theatre from Thursdays thru Sundays with all Sundays being Matinees

  5. Stellis Robinson

    I attended It Had to Be You, and enjoyed it. Had a great laugh – laughter good for the soul. I am now looking forward to seeing It Runs In the Family. Thanks for all that you do.

    • Steve Graham

      Thanks!.. we look forward to seeing you again.

  6. Joan OHara

    What shows are playing mid to end of december
    Do you give gift cards

    • Steve Graham

      November & December 2019, Herongate Presents “It Runs In The Family’ by Ray Cooney.
      Hilarious Farce takes place in a hospital at Christmas with the funiest cast ever assembled for a show! This plays through the Christmas week and on New Years Eve so book early to avoid dissappointment.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Pin It on Pinterest